Can You Ask a Contractor for Material Receipts?
Updated: 7 days ago
Can You Ask a Contractor for Material Receipts?
Can you ask a contractor for material receipts? The short answer is: most of the time, no.
On a fixed-price or turnkey project, homeowners generally should not expect a contractor to provide receipts or disclose their internal expense reports. Those are the contractor's business records.
However, there are exceptions, particularly depending on how your contract is structured. And whether or not you're entitled to see receipts, there are other ways to protect your investment and make sure the people supplying labor and materials to your project are being paid.
Fixed Price Contracts
A fixed-price quote, often presented as a proposal, is exactly what it sounds like: a contractor agrees to complete a defined scope of work for a set price.
When a contractor gives you a turnkey proposal, they have already done the work of estimating the costs involved in completing the project, including materials, labor, subcontractors, equipment, overhead, and profit. Those calculations are used to arrive at the price presented to you.
Once the scope and price are agreed upon and the contract is signed, that is generally the price you pay unless something changes, such as additional work, unforeseen conditions, or an approved change order.
So what does that mean when it comes to material receipts?
With a fixed-price contract, you are paying for the completed scope of work, not reimbursing the contractor for each individual expense.
For example, suppose a contractor estimated a certain price for mortar when preparing the bid. If the contractor later gets that mortar on sale, the homeowner doesn't automatically receive the savings. The reverse is generally true as well. If the price of that mortar increases after the contract is signed, the contractor may have to absorb that increase, depending on the terms of the contract.
That's part of the risk a contractor takes when agreeing to a fixed price.
For that reason, homeowners generally should not expect access to a contractor's material receipts, subcontractor invoices, or internal expense reports simply to determine whether the contractor made more or less money than expected.
That doesn't mean a homeowner should have no documentation or financial protection. There are situations where asking for receipts or other documentation is completely appropriate, and there are better ways to verify that suppliers and subcontractors are being pai
Unlike a fixed-price contract, some construction contracts base what you pay on the contractor's actual project costs. These are often structured as time-and-materials or cost-plus contracts, although the exact terms and pricing method can vary.
With a cost-plus arrangement, for example, the homeowner typically pays the actual cost of labor, materials, subcontractors, or other agreed project expenses, plus the contractor's agreed fee or markup.
In this situation, documentation becomes much more important because your final price is based on the contractor's actual costs. Your contract should spell out what documentation will be provided, which may include receipts, invoices, subcontractor bills, time records, or other proof of project expenses.
Let's go back to our mortar example.
Suppose the contractor estimated mortar at a certain price plus the agreed markup. When the mortar is actually purchased, it's on sale. If your contract requires you to pay the actual material cost plus markup, your charge would be based on that lower purchase price rather than the original estimated price.
Cost-plus arrangements can be useful when the final scope of work is difficult to predict. Restoration and repair work is a good example. Once you start opening walls or removing damaged materials from an older building, you may discover conditions that simply couldn't be seen when the original estimate was prepared.
That uncertainty can make establishing a realistic fixed price difficult. In those situations, a properly written cost-plus or time-and-materials agreement may make more sense for both the homeowner and the contractor.
So if receipts aren't normally how you protect yourself on a fixed-price job, what should you be asking for instead?
What to Ask for Instead of Receipts
There are several ways to protect yourself during a home build without asking your contractor to open up their books. It starts with choosing the right contractor.
Vet your contractor thoroughly. Look for an established reputation, appropriate experience for your project, references, insurance, and a history of completing the type of work you're hiring them to do.
If you're still choosing a contractor, read my guide on Vetting Your Contractor before you start comparing bids.
Once you've narrowed your choices, meet with two or three contractors individually. Give each contractor enough time to look at the project, ask questions, and explain how they would approach the work. You don't need to interview everyone in town. If the first few aren't a good fit, you can always continue your search.
Ask what type of contract they typically use and why. Understanding whether you're being offered a fixed-price, cost-plus, or time-and-materials agreement is important because it affects not only how you pay for the project, but also what financial documentation you should expect to receive.
And remember, the cheapest bid isn't necessarily the best bid.
When one proposal is significantly lower than the others, find out why. Compare the scope of work, materials, allowances, exclusions, construction methods, and payment terms. Two contractors may appear to be bidding on the same house while actually including very different things.
Protecting Your Payments
If you're working under a fixed-price contract, receipts aren't necessarily the best way to determine whether your money is being handled properly.
What matters more is documenting payments and protecting yourself from potential lien claims.
Before construction begins, your contract should clearly establish the payment or draw schedule and what documentation must accompany each payment. Depending on your project and applicable state law, that may include lien waivers or releases from the contractor, subcontractors, and suppliers.
Conditional and unconditional lien waivers serve different purposes, so it's important to use the appropriate document at the appropriate time. An unconditional waiver should not be treated as interchangeable with a conditional waiver when payment has not yet actually been received.
Lien laws and required waiver forms vary by state, so homeowners should make sure the documents being used comply with the requirements where the property is located.
The goal isn't to micromanage your contractor's expenses. It's to create a paper trail showing what you're paying, what the payment covers, and whether the people who could potentially make a claim against your property are being paid.
If your contractor is requesting money beyond the agreed draw schedule, read My Contractor Wants More Money. Am I Being Scammed? before making another payment.
Stay Organized From the Beginning
Contracts, bids, draw schedules, change orders, lien documents, inspections, selections, warranties, and receipts can pile up quickly during a home build.
That's exactly why I created the Texas Bricklady Home Build Package. It includes the planning and project-management tools I wish more homeowners had before construction ever started, including the Home Build Workbook, Digital Project Planner, lien waiver forms, change-order tools, payment tracking, and more.
Have another home-building question? Leave a comment. There's a good chance another homeowner is wondering the same thing.
Comments